14 September, 2020
Press Coverage of the HWBC H1 Office Review 2020
Catch up on the various press coverage of our H1 Office Review 2020 here.
Difficult Q2 as Covid-19 impacts the market.
‘May you live in interesting times’ – never has an old proverb seemed so apt for the last few months, in terms of economic and social upheaval to working and personal lives. While there was some talk of a dangerous virus in Q1, the impact did not fully hit until March when business and social life fell off a cliff.
The effect on the Dublin office market was immediate and market activity stalled in Q2, with take up less than 100,000 sq ft. This was not entirely unexpected, as most corporate occupiers put requirements on hold to assess the impact on their staff and business. Up to then the fundamentals of the market had been performing well, with record activity in Q1 and predictions of another strong year ahead. Rents had been recovering since 2015 back to pre-crash levels with strong levels of occupier demand, however we were in the late phase of this cycle with rents plateauing for the last 18 months. Most astute market observers would have been predicting a return to more normalised levels of tenant demand, and an increasingly cautious approach from developers to supply of new space.
How this differs from the last crash
This is the second major setback for the office market in 10 years, with some querying if the same drastic correction will occur in terms of rental levels and vacancy rates. In our view the conditions of this ‘black swan’ event are structurally different from the previous crash, and the market is in much better shape heading into this crisis. There are a number of principal differences to consider.
Take up
After record levels of market activity in Q1 with take up of 993,000 sq ft, the potential impact of Covid-19 is still to emerge in terms of full year take up and pressure on rental levels. Take up for H1 at 1.1m sq ft is below average and is likely to see the total for this year fall below 2m sq ft for the first time since 2012. Pre-Covid there were strong levels of tenant demand, and there is currently over 500,000 sq ft of deals in advanced negotiation with large tech requirements due to complete by year end. Not surprisingly, the tech sector dominated market transactions, with the top five all completed in Q1.
The impact of working from home
Office users both large and small are reviewing their occupational requirements and the future use of office space, to re-think what changes will be required going forward. Large corporate occupiers are only beginning to get staff back to the office, and this process is likely to run to at least year end before any real clarity emerges.
New working from home measures have worked well for most companies and no doubt will be a feature of the future work life balance. The increase in such policies is not new for a number of sectors and may not have the dramatic effect on office use and demand for space as some commentators have predicted. The technology sector has been leading this change to work practices for a number of years, and they are by far the largest driver for demand in the Dublin market. Large tech companies have typically operated on an occupancy rate of 50-70%, so working from home is not new to that sector and will impact their business model least. This is already evident in the US, with companies such as Amazon and Facebook proceeding with plans for large acquisitions of additional office space for continued expansion, showing further commitment to physical space.
Where the new practices will impact most is the professional and financial sectors such as banks, solicitors and accountants, who would normally operate on a near 100% occupancy model, with all staff typically having their own desk space. This is going to change going forward and will impact demand for space from these sectors, with many companies looking at ways to reduce physical footprints to reflect the new reality. However, dramatic cost savings may be difficult to achieve, as having fewer staff in the office will be offset somewhat by the requirement to have more space per employee to comply with new health and safety guidelines. The digital transformation to work practices was expected to take around 10 years and this is now being condensed into 12 months, which is a big adjustment for employers to make.
We expect Covid to have an impact on office use in the suburbs, as large occupiers consider the benefits of having a suburban base with shorter commute times, as part of the strategy and re-think of staff returning to the office. There are a number of large occupiers looking at the ‘hub and spoke’ model as opposed to the traditional single HQ, which combines a city hub with a strategic suburban location for a more flexible workspace and working style. The benefits of this strategy include lower costs and the option for staff not to travel to the city for everyday commutes, to improve work and life balance.
Outlook
There is no doubt the Dublin office market has received a severe shock with the arrival of Covid-19, and it is still too early to gauge the full impact on long term office use. There is no real evidence of headline rents moving lower, however a reduction in net effective rents and increased tenant incentives by year end would be a reasonable assumption.
We would expect a more cautious approach from developers yet to go on-site, so the supply of new space should begin to slow. The industry wide shut down will also have a knock-on effect on expected completions for 2020. To offset this, there is likely to be an increase in the amount of ‘grey space’ offered to the market, as companies look to dispose of surplus offices to implement increased working from home policies. This will be particularly evident within the CBD as the professional and financial sectors adjust to the new reality.
Given the strong run the market has had over the last number of years, a late cycle correction would not have been unexpected, but certainly not in the manner of the immediate hit in March which will take some time to fully play out. There is also the small matter of Brexit to be finalised by year end, and the outcome of trade negotiations and final agreements will be closely watched by the office sector.
Headline office rents (H1 2020)
| CBD (Grade A) | €60.00 – €62.00 per sq ft |
| Suburban (Grade A) | €30.00 – €32.00 per sq ft |
| Car spaces, city | €4,000 pa per car space |
| Car spaces, suburbs | €1,750 – €2,000 pa per car space |
Office statistics, H1 2020
| Take up | 1.10m sq ft |
| Vacancy rate, entire market | 8.0% |
| New completions, 2020 | 600,000 sq ft |
| Pre-committed on practical completion | 68.0% |
| Under construction, CBD | 5.45m sq ft |
| Under construction, suburbs | 750,000 sq ft |
CBD pipeline
| Year | Estimated full year completions (sq ft) | Pre-let / reserved (sq ft) | Available supply (sq ft) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 1.45m | 765,000 / 53% | 685,000 |
| 2021 | 2.61m | 1.4m / 54% | 1.21m |
| 2022 | 2.0m | 1.18m / 59% | 820,000 |
Top 5 office deals, 2020
| Building | Size (sq ft) | Tenant |
|---|---|---|
| One & Two South County, Leopardstown, D18 | 245,500 | Mastercard |
| Fitzwilliam 28, Fitzwilliam Street, D2 | 135,000 | Slack |
| One Park Place, Upper Hatch Street, D2 | 103,000 | Dropbox |
| Stemple Exchange, Blanchardstown, D15 | 85,000 | Guidewire |
| Block 1 Central Park, Leopardstown, D18 | 72,000 |
14 September, 2020
Catch up on the various press coverage of our H1 Office Review 2020 here.

Email PaulEmail: pscannell@hwbc.ie
08722604730872260473
In line with Government advice and for the benefit of everyone, HWBC's Harcourt Street offices are closed until further notice. We remain fully operational remotely and you should continue to contact us in the normal way. Contact details for all staff can be found by clicking on the link below, stay safe.
Find out more